PRESS PLAY>>>NOW TO WATCH THIS MONTH’S WELCOME VIDEO
Another season of holiday sales and advertising is so quickly coming to an end. It’s often said that this is the most important sales season of the year, and yet so much of the marketing efforts are so predictable–so redundant. Let’s look at some of this year’s efforts …what works and what doesn’t.
BLACK FRIDAY: I have to admit that I’m not a big fan of this sales event that makes more media noise than profits (as in the black). I think that most retailers have just shifted the sales revenues to earlier day parts so that now Black Friday has almost become Black Thursday Night and Friday Dawn. Then again, I started thinking about the successful post-Thanksgiving events of years gone by and remembered that the excitement was all part of the experience of shopping for Christmas presents and being caught up in the stores “dressed in holiday style”. To some extent, Black Friday has recaptured that excitement for many shoppers. Part of the new holiday tradition is to get to the store at the crack of dawn, or earlier (sometimes with the whole family) and take advantage of the super saver items. If more stores put as much effort and budget behind the rest of the holiday season—not to mention the rest of the year—there would be a lot more customers and a lot more revenue.
MACY’S: I have to hand it to the bastion of department store retailing.. From the parade to the multi-media assault every day leading up to Christmas, They really put out an effort to create the glory days of 34th Street. However, they—and Dillard’s, Sears, and the other traditional department stores—just seem to put as much on sale in as many one-day sales events as possible. There just doesn’t seem to be anything exciting to make all of the customers want to go into the store for the experience. The watch catalogue was well done, but boring. The fragrance catalogue was a cacophony of scents that make you want to peel each and every one of the scratch and sniffs just for exercise. But do they make you want to go there instead of Target, Kohl’s , Walmart or any of the specialty chains? I think not. Let’s get back to making the brand an exciting place to go and the gifts with your logo a symbol of something special and not just a one-day sale.
HYUNDAI: I think this is one of the great brand development strategies over the past several years and certainly has made this car one of the new powerhouse brands in the industry. However, this year’s holiday efforts (and a Hyundai would be a nice stocking stuffer) were really quite silly. A bunch of weirdo-looking singers and musicians singing poorly with brief shots of the cars didn’t live up to the new styling and certainly doesn’t compete with the great effort put forth by Lexus this year.
HALLMARK AND FOLGERS: These two brands with everyday products continue to do a great job at Christmas to bring back the traditions and feelings that make the holidays so great. Hallmark’s commercials outshone the 200 holiday movies that were featured on their cable network, and Folger’s spots are so good you can almost smell those mountain-grown beans brewing. Great spots. Well-placed.
KOHL’S AND JCPENNEY: Help save the forests! With all the circulars that fill the paper and mailboxes, it appears to me that these two must have printing subsidiaries that make more profit than the stores. They seem so redundant and I wish they would take some of the dollars spent in print and do something exciting in broadcast. Great stores, but please how about some brand statements to fight the discounters.
GAITHER HOMECOMING: I had the pleasure to attend the final Gaither Homecoming Christmas concert in Jacksonville, FL, last week. It was a moving, exciting experience even if you don’t like gospel music. However, what is most impressive is how Bill Gaither and his family and organization have built a brand that is so consistent and so on target in television, dvds, cds, magazines, books, programming, gifts, concerts, and events. The Gaithers have become a resounding success as a brand and yet have maintained a sincerity and down-home personality that keeps their brand in the hearts of thousands of loyal followers (and customers).
OFFICE MAX: OK, my family “elfed” ourselves again this year and shared it with our friends and families. I can’t help it, it’s so funny! This office supply store, however, knows that it takes more than good prices on laptops and thumb drives to win over customers in this competitive category.
These are just a few of many brands to look at. Overall, I think many retailers and other consumer brands have left the creativity at home when it comes to the holidays. And while retail sales have increased versus last year’s poor showing, there is so much more that could be done with some breakthrough thinking and creative execution to make this the season for branding as well as giving.
Merry Christmas!!
Ken
Recent Comments